Unity Jetbrains Rider Plugin cannot find Rider On Windows

The problem I am having is that when I open the unity project, go to my External Tools > External Script Editor it is set to “Open by file extension” instead of Rider. When I set it to rider it will work but when I close the editor and open it again it will always default to “Open by file extension”. 

How do I fix this so that it will stay on Rider so I do not have to keep re-assigning it. 
Im using Unity 2020.3.20f1, I have the JetBrains Rider Editor package version 3.0.34 and Rider version 2024.3

I have tried update/downgraded rider and the rider editor package with no luck. Any help would be appreciated!